Mohammed HijabJesus is God. Is it true or false statement?
GodLogicThat's a true statement.
Mohammed HijabGreat. No problem. Is that is of predication or identity? It'll be a predication. Okay. So, he has the quality of being divine. Yep.
GodLogicHe has the description of being divine. Yep. Okay.
Mohammed HijabSo, that means to say that the Father has this quality, the Son has this quality, and the Holy Spirit has this quality. They all have the nature. Okay, beautiful. And do they have a will? Yeah, they have the same will because will is a faculty of your essence. So,
GodLogicWait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait, hold on for a second. If they're the same in essence and the same in mind and they're the same in consciousness and the same in will and the same in attributes, that means they're one in the same person, aren't they? No, there's a relative identity. They're identical in essence, but they're not identical. There's a distinction in their personhood. Wait, wait, hold on. Hold on. If you hold the position of relative identity of Peter Geach, my response to it is the following. My response to it is in order for you to come to that conclusion, you have to have a relative identity framework. And a relative identity framework goes against predicate and propositional logic. And in particular, it goes against Leibniz's law, which means that in order for you to prove the Trinity, you have to allow contradictions. Do you, do you agree, do you agree with that? No. Uh, can you
Mohammed HijabYou have to reject propositional logic. I disagree with you. Reject classical logic. Yes or no?