You Cannot Defend The Trinity Logically

The Logical Impossibility of the Trinity

Mohammed HijabDo you think it's logically possible for a man to be God?

OpponentI believe God can do anything he wants.

Mohammed HijabAnything he wants. Can he cease to exist?

OpponentGod existed before existence.

Mohammed HijabYou said he can do whatever he wants. Can he cease to exist?

OpponentThe same question you're asking.

Mohammed HijabCan God lie?

OpponentHe cannot lie.

Mohammed HijabOkay. So, he cannot lie. But you said he can do whatever he wants.

OpponentHe cannot lie.

Mohammed HijabBut you said he can do whatever he wants.

OpponentSee how you you're diversing now.

Mohammed HijabYou said that God can do whatever he wants, right? Can God become a man?

OpponentHe can do what I just said. He can do whatever he wants.

Mohammed HijabCan lie. He spoke to—

OpponentCan God lie?

Mohammed HijabIt's not in his attributes.

OpponentCan God lie?

Mohammed HijabIt's not in his attributes. No.

OpponentBut can he lie?

Mohammed HijabIt's not in his attributes. Can, yes or no?

OpponentHe can.

Mohammed HijabSo therefore, God cannot do anything that he wants. Do you see the contradiction in what you said?

OpponentIt's not a contradiction.

Mohammed HijabIt's a contradiction. How is it?

OpponentBecause you said, let me tell you why it's a contradiction. You said God can do whatever he wants. I asked you, can God lie? You said no. So that's clear not everything he wants, is